Most Significant Votes: Goodman, Sonic Healthcare, SEEK, Mineral Resources, SGH, Fox Corp, News Corp, Amcor, Coty, Shoprite, Sasol, Whitbread.
In short Data centres and pay dominated the latest Southern Hemisphere votes: 26% backed a resolution on data centre disclosure at Goodman, SEEK took a first strike and lost a vote on CEO pay, and Mineral Resources withdrew a pay resolution facing defeat. Investors also targeted governance at Fox Corp and News Corp and a new CEO incentive at Shoprite.
Welcome to Most Significant Votes as we continue our blogs covering the Southern Hemisphere voting season (and those Northern Hemisphere votes that run alongside). As always, we identify the key AGM decisions that matter to asset owners and on which they may wish to hold their fund managers accountable.
As we’ve seen of late elsewhere, data centres are controversial in Australia. The nation’s largest property business, Goodman (AGM 19th November) has shifted nearly 80% of its development efforts into the segment, and faced a shareholder resolution asking for more disclosure, and by implication more caution, on data centre developments. This garnered unusually high support of 26% (including 3% abstentions). Goodman also faced a bruising on pay, with 33% opposition to its remuneration report (including 7% abstentions) and 43% declining to support incentive awards to each of 3 executives. The company is switching its top executives from a scheme with a 10-year horizon to a 5-year one, which shareholders worry is less consistent with the long lead times for value-creation in the property business.
Pay was also the key issue elsewhere in Australia. At diagnostics firm Sonic Healthcare (AGM 19th November), while the remuneration report got off relatively lightly with only 10% opposition, two pay schemes which would allow significant further dilution of shareholders faced 38% votes against. Tech business SEEK (AGM 18th November) has had a difficult year, with performance issues in its (in theory) ‘growth’ fund of technology investments, and its share price roughly halving. Investors are clearly grumpy with the job-search firm, particularly feeling that pay doesn’t reflect this underperformance. A one-off A$225,000 award to CFO Kendra Banks in addition to existing incentives won’t have helped the mood. There was 37% opposition to the remuneration report, well above the 25% threshold that amounts to a ‘strike’ and so raises the possibility of a vote to remove the whole board next year. More striking than this was the defeat of one of the resolutions on equity incentive awards to the CEO Ian Narev – this was against the A$1.2 million ‘equity right’, which with a two-year horizon looks short-term compared to normal equity incentives, but at SEEK substitutes for the annual bonus – backed up with a 24% vote against a second such resolution, regarding his A$4 million long-term share incentive. Almost as notable as this were the votes against the reappointment of two directors, apparently because they are members of the remuneration committee: 28% and 26% against Vanessa Wallace and Jamaludin Ibrahim respectively.
We must assume that a pay resolution at Mineral Resources (AGM 18th November) was also defeated, though the company formally withdrew it the day before the meeting. In that announcement, the iron and lithium miner said that the potential termination benefits was “close to” passing, but the preliminary votes actually disclosed show 54% opposition, so a margin of defeat of some 8 percentage points. In addition, there was 28% vote against a resolution on incentive awards for CEO Chris Ellison, and 19% against the remuneration report. On each of these resolutions, Ellison, himself a 10% shareholder, was precluded from voting. The controversy at MinRes surrounded an investigation by securities regulator ASIC, closed only at the start of September, into alleged tax evasion over undisclosed related party transactions with entities in which Ellison had an interest. When the story emerged in 2024, it was said Ellison would leave the company by the end of 2025 – and though the company continues to talk about succession planning (and broader governance and related party transaction reviews), he’s still there.
There appears to be a broad underlying disquiet among shareholders about construction materials supplier, plant hire and gas conglomerate SGH (AGM 13th November), with all but one of the 6 resolutions reaching double-digit opposition from institutional investors. Given a range of other roles, new chair John Gillam is seen to be too busy and probably is also held to account for the low diversity of the board, with only 2 women of the 9 directors: 5% of shareholders opposed his election, or 14% when the 51% shareholding of the dominant Stokes family is set to one side. Vik Bansal is acknowledged to be a non-independent director, having been CEO of business unit Boral and having joined the SGH board initially, and briefly, as an executive before becoming an NED. He’s already sitting on key board committees. 6% of shareholders, or 16% other than the Stokeses, opposed his reappointment. Non-executives Chris Mackay and Warwick Smith also both have questionable independence, having served on the board for 16 and 12 years respectively; 9% (22%) and 5% (13%) voted against their re-elections. The remuneration report also picked up 8% (or 19%) opposition. Stokes scion Ryan received A$15.6 million in the year, but perhaps more pertinent to investor decision-making was the A$1.5 million special retention award given to CFO Richard Richards during the year, half of which vested within the year; this was in addition to his usual pay and incentive package.
We’ll consider a pair of US companies with a decidedly Australian accent alongside each other. Following a deal within the family, both Fox Corp (AGM 4th November) and News Corp (AGM 5th November) are dominated by the eldest Murdoch son Lachlan, who controls 39% and 35% of their respective voting shares (those most available to outside investors carry no voting rights at all). At each company, Lachlan himself faced significant opposition, probably because he is seen to be overcommitted given holding both executive chair roles: 15% (or 26% of the voting shareholders other than himself) at Fox and 7% (or 12%) at News. But the most-opposed director in each case was the chair of the corporate governance committee, usually a mark of concern from investors about structural failings – in this case likely the dual class share structure. Both individuals are rightwing politicians: at Fox, former Republican speaker of the House of Representatives Paul Ryan faced 22% (39%) opposition; and at News, former Spanish Prime Minister Jose Maria Aznar faced 18% (32%). Finally, there was also a shareholder resolution at Fox, calling for all voting decisions to be made according to a majority of shareholder votes, removing any requirements for supermajority approval. It’s far from clear whether the 39% (69% other than Lachlan) of investors who backed this have thought through what such a call might imply in the context of a dual class share structure with such a significant proportion of the votes held in a single individual’s hands.
Also Australian-accented is now Jersey-incorporated packager Amcor (AGM 11th November). Despite a small flurry of additional disclosures on pay matters, clearly designed to assuage concerns expressed by investors and the proxy agencies, the company wasn’t able to put those worries to rest for all: 21% opposed the vote on executive pay. The ongoing sore appears to have been one-off deal-related awards to incentivise performance following the acquisition of Berry Global. Many investors dislike pay schemes linked to deals and instead expect performance to be rewarded through ongoing incentive structures.
Following an ugly and prolonged performance and share price decline, US beauty firm Coty (AGM 5th November) saw wholesale board changes in 2026. Not all the new directors were welcomed, with Patricia Capel facing 5% opposition, or 13% once the majority holding of her employer JAB Holdings (the investment vehicle of the billionaire Reimann family) is excluded. Given Capel isn’t the only JAB-linked director on the board, the investor reasoning for opposition appears to be how busy she is (as well as her people responsibilities within JAB itself, she chairs Krispy Kreme and is on the board of at least 3 other sizeable JAB investments) rather than independence per se. The new board also proposed to make more shares available under an executive incentive scheme: nearly 6% of the stock, which it states it is likely to use up in just 3 years. 2% dilution annually is an aggressive level for such a mature company: 10% of shareholders, or 27% other than JAB, opposed this.
South African retailer Shoprite (AGM 6th November) – the nation’s largest private sector employer – faced strident criticism over pay. Concerns focused on a new incentive scheme proposed specifically just for the benefit of CEO Pieter Engelbrecht. Though ostensibly a six-year scheme, performance is measured on an annual basis and a sixth portion of shares can vest (though not be paid out) each year, and then in effect retested each year because all performance criteria are measured on a cumulative basis. Its value at award is over R150 million, and this is in addition to Engelbrecht’s existing pay and incentives – he received R118 million in total last year. 29% of investors opposed the new scheme, or fully 54% once the votes of non-executive director Christo Wiese, who controls all the (voting) deferred shares as well as 11% of the ordinaries, are set aside. In addition, 14% (or 27% other than Wiese) voted against the remuneration report.
Also in South Africa, the country’s coal-to-liquids fossil fuel giant Sasol (AGM 13th November) for the first time for several years did not put its climate approach up for shareholder consideration and approval – a resolution that’s faced regular investor concern. The move didn’t mean that the company avoided controversy, however, with 22% opposition to the re-election of Manuel Cuambe, whose long tenure as a non-executive means he is not seen by all shareholders as independent, and a 14% vote against the remuneration policy. This may have been driven by the fact that the new policy removes an incentive to cut carbon emissions.
Finally, in the UK, Whitbread (EGM 9th November) successfully saw off a board tilt by activist investor Corvex Management. Corvex has been agitating for change to the capex plans of the company behind Premier Inn for two years, and sought to add its partner James Gemmel to the board. Headline support was 17% for this proposal, but the company notes that once the Corvex shareholding is set aside this number was more like 9%.
That’s it for this fortnight. Check back in two weeks’ time for the next edition.
Don’t want to miss an issue? Subscribe to our newsletter at the bottom of the page.